La consulta popular en México: un replanteamiento para superarlainoperabilidad a la luz de los primeros resultados y los modelos Latinoamericanos.

The figure of popular consultation recently emerged in the Mexican legal framework alongside the citizen initiative and the independent governments.By virtue of this new tool of democratic participation, it is necessary to question about the efficiency of it (a question that must be analyzed in the...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal: López Sáenz, Emanuel
Formato: Artículo
Lenguaje:español
Publicado: Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León - UANL 2017
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://revpoliticas.uanl.mx/index.php/RPGyC/article/view/49
_version_ 1824327914090397696
author López Sáenz, Emanuel
author_facet López Sáenz, Emanuel
author_sort López Sáenz, Emanuel
collection Artículos de Revistas UANL
description The figure of popular consultation recently emerged in the Mexican legal framework alongside the citizen initiative and the independent governments.By virtue of this new tool of democratic participation, it is necessary to question about the efficiency of it (a question that must be analyzed in the other two), assesing the aspects to be improved –if applicable-in order to give full validity to the emphatic attempt, to create more solid links between the government and the participation of its citizens, condition that strengthens a country’s governance.This approach arises, since an analysis of the fisrt cases to conduct varied popular consultations in the electoral day from 2015 was done and all the requests studied were dismissed by the Highest Court, who is previously in charge of the analysis of the constitutionality of the consultations, stating that, all the raised issues were prohibited by the Constitution.This has led to a recent debate in different latitudes about the suitability of reformulate the figure, since it is nowadays a model of participation that seeks to empower the citizen, however, from the 2015 experience and with the aim of providing full validity to the civilian right of participating, is convenient to study the constitutional limitations not to plumb in the depths of absurdity having on one side the constitutional requirement of national transcendence, an on the other hand, theinconstitutionality and therefore the inoperativity of the consultation by the extent of the contitutional restrictions. For all these reasons, a methodological study of comparative law was initiated, for purposes of studyng the regulations and best practices from countries that already count with similar consultation figures, which cast some conclusions.
first_indexed 2025-02-05T22:51:31Z
format Article
id revpoliticas-article-49
institution UANL
language spa
last_indexed 2025-02-05T22:51:31Z
physical Política, Globalidad y Ciudadanía; Vol. 2 No. 4 (2016): July - December; 1
Revista Política, Globalidad y Ciudadanía; Vol. 2 Núm. 4 (2016): Julio - Diciembre; 1
2395-8448
publishDate 2017
publisher Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León - UANL
record_format ojs
spelling revpoliticas-article-492023-07-20T22:17:02Z Popular consultation in Mexico: a reformulation to overcome the inoperability in the light of the first outcomes and Latinamerican models. La consulta popular en México: un replanteamiento para superarlainoperabilidad a la luz de los primeros resultados y los modelos Latinoamericanos. López Sáenz, Emanuel popular consultation constitutional right comparative law Consulta popular derecho constitucional derecho comparado The figure of popular consultation recently emerged in the Mexican legal framework alongside the citizen initiative and the independent governments. By virtue of this new tool of democratic participation, it is necessary to question about the efficiency of it (a question that must be analyzed in the other two), assesing the aspects to be improved –if applicable- in order to give full validity to the emphatic attempt, to create more solid links between the government and the participation of its citizens, condition that strengthens a country’s governance. This approach arises, since an analysis of the fisrt cases to conduct varied popular consultations in the electoral day from 2015 was done and all the requests studied were dismissed by the Highest Court, who is previously in charge of the analysis of the constitutionality of the consultations, stating that, all the raised issues were prohibited by the Constitution. This has led to a recent debate in different latitudes about the suitability of reformulate the figure, since it is nowadays a model of participation that seeks to empower the citizen, however, from the 2015 experience and with the aim of providing full validity to the civilian right of participating, is convenient to study the constitutional limitations not to plumb in the depths of absurdity having on one side the constitutional requirement of national transcendence, an on the other hand, the inconstitutionality and therefore the inoperativity of the consultation by the extent of the contitutional restrictions.  For all these reasons, a methodological study of comparative law was initiated, for purposes of studyng the regulations and best practices from countries that already count with similar consultation figures, which cast some conclusions. The figure of popular consultation recently emerged in the Mexican legal framework alongside the citizen initiative and the independent governments.By virtue of this new tool of democratic participation, it is necessary to question about the efficiency of it (a question that must be analyzed in the other two), assesing the aspects to be improved –if applicable-in order to give full validity to the emphatic attempt, to create more solid links between the government and the participation of its citizens, condition that strengthens a country’s governance.This approach arises, since an analysis of the fisrt cases to conduct varied popular consultations in the electoral day from 2015 was done and all the requests studied were dismissed by the Highest Court, who is previously in charge of the analysis of the constitutionality of the consultations, stating that, all the raised issues were prohibited by the Constitution.This has led to a recent debate in different latitudes about the suitability of reformulate the figure, since it is nowadays a model of participation that seeks to empower the citizen, however, from the 2015 experience and with the aim of providing full validity to the civilian right of participating, is convenient to study the constitutional limitations not to plumb in the depths of absurdity having on one side the constitutional requirement of national transcendence, an on the other hand, theinconstitutionality and therefore the inoperativity of the consultation by the extent of the contitutional restrictions. For all these reasons, a methodological study of comparative law was initiated, for purposes of studyng the regulations and best practices from countries that already count with similar consultation figures, which cast some conclusions. Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León - UANL 2017-08-01 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://revpoliticas.uanl.mx/index.php/RPGyC/article/view/49 Política, Globalidad y Ciudadanía; Vol. 2 No. 4 (2016): July - December; 1 Revista Política, Globalidad y Ciudadanía; Vol. 2 Núm. 4 (2016): Julio - Diciembre; 1 2395-8448 spa https://revpoliticas.uanl.mx/index.php/RPGyC/article/view/49/43 Copyright (c) 2017 Política, Globalidad y Ciudadanía https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0
spellingShingle popular consultation
constitutional right
comparative law
Consulta popular
derecho constitucional
derecho comparado
López Sáenz, Emanuel
La consulta popular en México: un replanteamiento para superarlainoperabilidad a la luz de los primeros resultados y los modelos Latinoamericanos.
thumbnail https://rediab.uanl.mx/themes/sandal5/images/article.gif
title La consulta popular en México: un replanteamiento para superarlainoperabilidad a la luz de los primeros resultados y los modelos Latinoamericanos.
title_alt Popular consultation in Mexico: a reformulation to overcome the inoperability in the light of the first outcomes and Latinamerican models.
title_full La consulta popular en México: un replanteamiento para superarlainoperabilidad a la luz de los primeros resultados y los modelos Latinoamericanos.
title_fullStr La consulta popular en México: un replanteamiento para superarlainoperabilidad a la luz de los primeros resultados y los modelos Latinoamericanos.
title_full_unstemmed La consulta popular en México: un replanteamiento para superarlainoperabilidad a la luz de los primeros resultados y los modelos Latinoamericanos.
title_short La consulta popular en México: un replanteamiento para superarlainoperabilidad a la luz de los primeros resultados y los modelos Latinoamericanos.
title_sort la consulta popular en mexico un replanteamiento para superarlainoperabilidad a la luz de los primeros resultados y los modelos latinoamericanos
topic popular consultation
constitutional right
comparative law
Consulta popular
derecho constitucional
derecho comparado
topic_facet popular consultation
constitutional right
comparative law
Consulta popular
derecho constitucional
derecho comparado
url https://revpoliticas.uanl.mx/index.php/RPGyC/article/view/49
work_keys_str_mv AT lopezsaenzemanuel popularconsultationinmexicoareformulationtoovercometheinoperabilityinthelightofthefirstoutcomesandlatinamericanmodels
AT lopezsaenzemanuel laconsultapopularenmexicounreplanteamientoparasuperarlainoperabilidadalaluzdelosprimerosresultadosylosmodeloslatinoamericanos