Posaconazole MIC Distributions for Aspergillus fumigatus Species Complex by Four Methods: Impact of cyp51A Mutations on Estimation of Epidemiological Cutoff Values
ABSTRACT Estimating epidemiological cutoff endpoints (ECVs/ECOFFS) may be hindered by the overlap of MICs for mutant and nonmutant strains (strains harboring or not harboring mutations, respectively). Posaconazole MIC distributions for the Aspergillus fumigatus species complex were collected from 26...
| Main Authors: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
|---|---|
| Format: | Article |
| Language: | English |
| Published: |
American Society for Microbiology
2018
|
| Subjects: | |
| Online Access: | http://eprints.uanl.mx/16313/1/158.pdf |
| _version_ | 1824414572755288064 |
|---|---|
| author | Espinel Ingroff, A. Turnidge, J. Alastruey Izquierdo, A. Dannaoui, E. García Effron, G. Guinea, J. Kidd, S. E. Pelaez, T. Sanguinetti, M. Meletiadis, J. Botterel, F. Bustamante, B. Chen, Y.-C. Chakrabarti, A. Chowdhary, A. Chryssanthou, E. Córdoba, S. González González, Gloria María Guarro, Josep Johnson, E. M. Kus, J. V. Lass Flörl, Cornelia Linares Sicilia, M. J. Martín Mazuelos, E. Negri, C. E. Pfaller, M. A. Tortorano, A. M. |
| author_facet | Espinel Ingroff, A. Turnidge, J. Alastruey Izquierdo, A. Dannaoui, E. García Effron, G. Guinea, J. Kidd, S. E. Pelaez, T. Sanguinetti, M. Meletiadis, J. Botterel, F. Bustamante, B. Chen, Y.-C. Chakrabarti, A. Chowdhary, A. Chryssanthou, E. Córdoba, S. González González, Gloria María Guarro, Josep Johnson, E. M. Kus, J. V. Lass Flörl, Cornelia Linares Sicilia, M. J. Martín Mazuelos, E. Negri, C. E. Pfaller, M. A. Tortorano, A. M. |
| author_sort | Espinel Ingroff, A. |
| collection | Repositorio Institucional |
| description | ABSTRACT Estimating epidemiological cutoff endpoints (ECVs/ECOFFS) may be hindered by the overlap of MICs for mutant and nonmutant strains (strains harboring or not harboring mutations, respectively). Posaconazole MIC distributions for the Aspergillus fumigatus species complex were collected from 26 laboratories (in Australia, Canada, Europe, India, South and North America, and Taiwan) and published studies. Distributions that fulfilled CLSI criteria were pooled and ECVs were estimated. The sensitivity of three ECV analytical techniques (the ECOFFinder, normalized resistance interpretation [NRI], derivatization methods) to the inclusion of MICs for mutants was examined for three susceptibility testing methods (the CLSI, EUCAST, and Etest methods). The totals of posaconazole MICs for nonmutant isolates (isolates with no known cyp51A mutations) and mutant A. fumigatus isolates were as follows: by the CLSI method, 2,223 and 274, respectively; by the EUCAST method, 556 and 52, respectively; and by Etest, 1,365 and 29, respectively. MICs for 381 isolates with unknown mutational status were also evaluated with the Sensititre YeastOne system (SYO). We observed an overlap in posaconazole MICs among nonmutants and cyp51A mutants. At the commonly chosen percentage of the modeled wild-type population (97.5%), almost all ECVs remained the same when the MICs for nonmutant and mutant distributions were merged: ECOFFinder ECVs, 0.5 μg/ml for the CLSI method and 0.25 μg/ml for the EUCAST method and Etest; NRI ECVs, 0.5 μg/ml for all three methods. However, the ECOFFinder ECV for 95% of the nonmutant population by the CLSI method was 0.25 μg/ml. The tentative ECOFFinder ECV with SYO was 0.06 μg/ml (data from 3/8 laboratories). Derivatization ECVs with or without mutant inclusion were either 0.25 μg/ml (CLSI, EUCAST, Etest) or 0.06 μg/ml (SYO). It appears that ECV analytical techniques may not be vulnerable to overlap between presumptive wild-type isolates and cyp51A mutants when up to 11.6% of the estimated wild-type population includes mutants.
KEYWORDS Aspergillus fumigatus, CLSI ECVs, ECVs, EUCAST ECVs, Etest, SYO, cyp51A mutants, posaconazole, triazole resistance, wild type |
| format | Article |
| id | eprints-16313 |
| institution | UANL |
| language | English |
| publishDate | 2018 |
| publisher | American Society for Microbiology |
| record_format | eprints |
| spelling | eprints-163132024-03-05T17:54:24Z http://eprints.uanl.mx/16313/ Posaconazole MIC Distributions for Aspergillus fumigatus Species Complex by Four Methods: Impact of cyp51A Mutations on Estimation of Epidemiological Cutoff Values Espinel Ingroff, A. Turnidge, J. Alastruey Izquierdo, A. Dannaoui, E. García Effron, G. Guinea, J. Kidd, S. E. Pelaez, T. Sanguinetti, M. Meletiadis, J. Botterel, F. Bustamante, B. Chen, Y.-C. Chakrabarti, A. Chowdhary, A. Chryssanthou, E. Córdoba, S. González González, Gloria María Guarro, Josep Johnson, E. M. Kus, J. V. Lass Flörl, Cornelia Linares Sicilia, M. J. Martín Mazuelos, E. Negri, C. E. Pfaller, M. A. Tortorano, A. M. RM Terapéutica, Farmacología ABSTRACT Estimating epidemiological cutoff endpoints (ECVs/ECOFFS) may be hindered by the overlap of MICs for mutant and nonmutant strains (strains harboring or not harboring mutations, respectively). Posaconazole MIC distributions for the Aspergillus fumigatus species complex were collected from 26 laboratories (in Australia, Canada, Europe, India, South and North America, and Taiwan) and published studies. Distributions that fulfilled CLSI criteria were pooled and ECVs were estimated. The sensitivity of three ECV analytical techniques (the ECOFFinder, normalized resistance interpretation [NRI], derivatization methods) to the inclusion of MICs for mutants was examined for three susceptibility testing methods (the CLSI, EUCAST, and Etest methods). The totals of posaconazole MICs for nonmutant isolates (isolates with no known cyp51A mutations) and mutant A. fumigatus isolates were as follows: by the CLSI method, 2,223 and 274, respectively; by the EUCAST method, 556 and 52, respectively; and by Etest, 1,365 and 29, respectively. MICs for 381 isolates with unknown mutational status were also evaluated with the Sensititre YeastOne system (SYO). We observed an overlap in posaconazole MICs among nonmutants and cyp51A mutants. At the commonly chosen percentage of the modeled wild-type population (97.5%), almost all ECVs remained the same when the MICs for nonmutant and mutant distributions were merged: ECOFFinder ECVs, 0.5 μg/ml for the CLSI method and 0.25 μg/ml for the EUCAST method and Etest; NRI ECVs, 0.5 μg/ml for all three methods. However, the ECOFFinder ECV for 95% of the nonmutant population by the CLSI method was 0.25 μg/ml. The tentative ECOFFinder ECV with SYO was 0.06 μg/ml (data from 3/8 laboratories). Derivatization ECVs with or without mutant inclusion were either 0.25 μg/ml (CLSI, EUCAST, Etest) or 0.06 μg/ml (SYO). It appears that ECV analytical techniques may not be vulnerable to overlap between presumptive wild-type isolates and cyp51A mutants when up to 11.6% of the estimated wild-type population includes mutants. KEYWORDS Aspergillus fumigatus, CLSI ECVs, ECVs, EUCAST ECVs, Etest, SYO, cyp51A mutants, posaconazole, triazole resistance, wild type American Society for Microbiology 2018 Article PeerReviewed text en cc_by_nc_nd http://eprints.uanl.mx/16313/1/158.pdf http://eprints.uanl.mx/16313/1.haspreviewThumbnailVersion/158.pdf Espinel Ingroff, A. y Turnidge, J. y Alastruey Izquierdo, A. y Dannaoui, E. y García Effron, G. y Guinea, J. y Kidd, S. E. y Pelaez, T. y Sanguinetti, M. y Meletiadis, J. y Botterel, F. y Bustamante, B. y Chen, Y.-C. y Chakrabarti, A. y Chowdhary, A. y Chryssanthou, E. y Córdoba, S. y González González, Gloria María y Guarro, Josep y Johnson, E. M. y Kus, J. V. y Lass Flörl, Cornelia y Linares Sicilia, M. J. y Martín Mazuelos, E. y Negri, C. E. y Pfaller, M. A. y Tortorano, A. M. (2018) Posaconazole MIC Distributions for Aspergillus fumigatus Species Complex by Four Methods: Impact of cyp51A Mutations on Estimation of Epidemiological Cutoff Values. Antimicrobial agents and chemotherapy, 62 (4). pp. 1-11. ISSN 0066-4804 http://doi.org/10.1128/AAC.01916-17 doi:10.1128/AAC.01916-17 |
| spellingShingle | RM Terapéutica, Farmacología Espinel Ingroff, A. Turnidge, J. Alastruey Izquierdo, A. Dannaoui, E. García Effron, G. Guinea, J. Kidd, S. E. Pelaez, T. Sanguinetti, M. Meletiadis, J. Botterel, F. Bustamante, B. Chen, Y.-C. Chakrabarti, A. Chowdhary, A. Chryssanthou, E. Córdoba, S. González González, Gloria María Guarro, Josep Johnson, E. M. Kus, J. V. Lass Flörl, Cornelia Linares Sicilia, M. J. Martín Mazuelos, E. Negri, C. E. Pfaller, M. A. Tortorano, A. M. Posaconazole MIC Distributions for Aspergillus fumigatus Species Complex by Four Methods: Impact of cyp51A Mutations on Estimation of Epidemiological Cutoff Values |
| thumbnail | https://rediab.uanl.mx/themes/sandal5/images/online.png |
| title | Posaconazole MIC Distributions for Aspergillus fumigatus Species Complex by Four Methods: Impact of cyp51A Mutations on Estimation of Epidemiological Cutoff Values |
| title_full | Posaconazole MIC Distributions for Aspergillus fumigatus Species Complex by Four Methods: Impact of cyp51A Mutations on Estimation of Epidemiological Cutoff Values |
| title_fullStr | Posaconazole MIC Distributions for Aspergillus fumigatus Species Complex by Four Methods: Impact of cyp51A Mutations on Estimation of Epidemiological Cutoff Values |
| title_full_unstemmed | Posaconazole MIC Distributions for Aspergillus fumigatus Species Complex by Four Methods: Impact of cyp51A Mutations on Estimation of Epidemiological Cutoff Values |
| title_short | Posaconazole MIC Distributions for Aspergillus fumigatus Species Complex by Four Methods: Impact of cyp51A Mutations on Estimation of Epidemiological Cutoff Values |
| title_sort | posaconazole mic distributions for aspergillus fumigatus species complex by four methods impact of cyp51a mutations on estimation of epidemiological cutoff values |
| topic | RM Terapéutica, Farmacología |
| url | http://eprints.uanl.mx/16313/1/158.pdf |
| work_keys_str_mv | AT espinelingroffa posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT turnidgej posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT alastrueyizquierdoa posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT dannaouie posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT garciaeffrong posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT guineaj posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT kiddse posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT pelaezt posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT sanguinettim posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT meletiadisj posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT botterelf posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT bustamanteb posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT chenyc posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT chakrabartia posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT chowdharya posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT chryssanthoue posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT cordobas posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT gonzalezgonzalezgloriamaria posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT guarrojosep posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT johnsonem posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT kusjv posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT lassflorlcornelia posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT linaressiciliamj posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT martinmazuelose posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT negrice posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT pfallerma posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues AT tortoranoam posaconazolemicdistributionsforaspergillusfumigatusspeciescomplexbyfourmethodsimpactofcyp51amutationsonestimationofepidemiologicalcutoffvalues |